HEBREW TABERNACLE CONGREGATION
Ethan Newman

June 12, 2010

D’var Torah

 


 

EthanBrown.JPG

 

Ethan is currently a seventh grader at the Institute for Collaborative Education. He enjoys playing baseball, football, basketball, and most of all soccer. Ethan has played on teams since he was five years old. Healso takes private tenor saxophone lessons and plays for the ICE Middle School band. Ethan looks forward to attending Camp Baco in the Adirondacks this summer. He is an avid New York Mets fan and loves to spend time with his friends and family.

 

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

 

 

This week’s Torah portion describes a disgruntled group of people, led by Korach,

 

Datan and Aviram, who are unhappy with the leadership of Moses and Aaron.  The

 

narrative takes place in the desert where our ancestors were journeying towards the

 

Promised Land.  Korach was a Levite and so were most of his followers. Levites

 

were  assistants to the priests, so they knew a lot about the required animal sacrifices

 

as well as looking after the sacred furnishings of the Tabernacle.  Korach thought,

 

“What right do Moses and Aaron have to be our leaders?” What did Moses, under

 

God’s instruction do about this?  He told the people that followed Korach to go to

 

the tent of meeting and told them to bring fire pans for making a fire offering to

 

God, so God could choose who is holy.  During the day of reckoning, God

 

opened a hole in the earth  that swallowed up the ringleaders of the rebellion.

 

Furthermore, God made the fire consume the 250 people that had supported Korach.

 

When some Jews blamed Moses and Aaron for the death of these people. God

 

became angry and caused a plague to kill 14,700 more people.  The defiance against

 

Moses and Aaron was considered to be defiance against God.

 

 

 

What I found interesting is that people still got upset after God had killed the 250

 

supporters of Korach.  They had already witnessed the power of God, so why would

 

they defy God again?  After witnessing how God crushed Korach’s rebellion with

 

one blow, wouldn’t they be afraid to speak out against God?  The Jews challenged

 

God again because they felt that the 250 rebels did not deserve to die.  How could

 

they worship a god whom they perceived as a mass murderer?

 

 

 

I think that God has gotten kinder in the past 3000 years or so.  Humanity has done

 

many foolish and horrible things that could have easily made God angry.

 

Throughout history, other nations have defamed the Jewish religion as well as

 

persecuted and murdered their Jewish populations.  This has occurred many times

 

throughout history, yet God appears to be silent.  Does that mean that God has

 

become kinder and more forgiving?  We cannot predict what God will do next.  We

 

don’t really have a way of telling whether God is angry or happy, except when we pray

 

to him.  I believe that God is generally happy and pleased.  Maybe it is because many

 

Jews are still loyal to God, continue to pray in synagogues and have not lost faith.

 

Perhaps that is why God hasn’t crushed another rebellion as in the days of Korach.

 

 

If this is so, how can we explain the senseless murder of Jews in the modern age?  I

 

don’t think that God wanted all of these Jews to die.  The perpetrators of the

 

Holocaust were obviously blinded by hate and rage against the Jews.  I believe the

 

difference between the slaughtering of Korach’s followers and the death of Jews

 

during modern history is that God didn’t cause these to happen.

 

 

 

Throughout the ages, there have been people that argued that Judaism is a false

 

religion or that Jews are an inferior race, or that there is a Zionist conspiracy to take

 

over the world.  In the twenty first century, I believe that all of these theories should

 

be put to rest and replaced by universal religious tolerance.  I believe that no matter

 

how much we oppose other faiths’ traditions, we should try not to change other

 

people’s religions or beliefs.  I don’t believe in religious propaganda.  I think that if

 

someone wants to change religions, it is up to them to make that decision.

 

This Torah portion inspired me to think about human nature and how we never

 

learn from our mistakes, even though we may adapt and thrive.

 

 

 

In the book, Lord  of the Flies by William Golding, a group of children were

 

stranded on a deserted  island, low on supplies and had to choose a leader from

 

their group.  Ralph was chosen as the leader, but some children in the group didn’t

 

want him to continue as the leader.  Like Moses, Ralph was not corrupt in any

 

way.  Just as was the case with Korach and his followers, Jack and his followers in

 

Lord of the Flies simply wanted to seize power for themselves.  As in the case of

 

Korach’s rebellion, there was violence and bloodshed and a lot of children died or

 

were injured.  In this situation, God did not intervene.  Only the adults appeared at

 

the end of the book to rescue the children who survived.

 

 

 

Some commentators wrote that in Parshat Korach, there were different groups of

 

rebels who had different reasons why they disliked Moses.  If the rebellion had

 

actually succeeded, the different groups would probably have ended up fighting

 

amongst themselves.  The conflict wasn’t really about God at all!!! It was all about

 

power!!!  Like God, I like to cooperate with my friends and peers and so do my

 

parents.  I need cooperation from people and they need cooperation from me.

 

 

Like most people, I work better in groups when we get along.  If people are arguing,

 

nothing gets done and it can get heavy on my shoulders, which I don’t like. God

 

also needed cooperation to help get the Jews out of the desert and to the safety of

 

Canaan.

 

I would like to thank my parents for making this all possible, for setting up

 

my bar mitzvah and doing all the fun stuff like arranging the party.  I would also

 

like to thank my Mom for reading from the Torah and my Dad for volunteering

 

with me.  I would like to thank the most helpful tutor in the world, Nina Nesher.  I

 

want to thank my brother for being my brother and encouraging me and sometimes

 

telling me that it won’t be so hard to do.  I would like to thank my friends for being

 

there for me and accepting the fact that I couldn’t do something with them because I

 

had to prepare for today.  I would like to thank my Hebrew School friends for

 

making Hebrew School more interesting.  I would like to thank my Hebrew School

 

teachers, especially Neil and Jillian and Shelly Koy, our wonderful principal.

 

Finally, I want to thank all of you for being here today, for cheering me on and

 

helping me through this entire experience.

 

Shabbat Shalom

 

 


  Return to the Main Homepage

Hebrew Tabernacle Congregation

551 Fort Washington Avenue
New York, New York 10033
Tel: 212-568-8304
Fax: 212-927-5428
E-Mail :
office@hebrewtabernacle.org